Skip to content
• | 

Is it just us, or are the Christmas markets good again?

Ethan enjoys a Löwenbräu. Photo: Ophira Gottlieb/The Mill

This is not a paid ad, we promise

It was November 2024. The Spanish King had not long been pelted with mud. An heir to a pie fortune was found guilty of murdering their best friend in Cardiff, and a banana duct-taped to a wall had just sold for $6.2 million — in a few days’ time it would be eaten. Storm Bert was on the horizon, and in our little office in the Royal Exchange, a tempest of another form brewed.

Long-time Mill subscribers will no doubt remember the Christmas Market Wars. Two years ago, Mill-defector Jack Walton (he now works for our Birmingham paper) and I (Ophira) were instructed by Mill-defector Sophie Atkinson (she now works for our Liverpool paper) to go head-to-head answering the question: is it time our festive markets were ‘binned off’? I was to take the anti-market stance, and Jack was to be pro. The late Pat Karney – official Christmas spokesperson for the council – would later refer to the article as a “wokish low volume debate”.

Then a year later, I was tasked with writing an altogether different Christmas market affair. I was to profile Karney himself, in an interview so scandalous it had Mill readers publicly calling for his imprisonment. The big wheel had just made its grand return to the newly re-opened Albert Square, and I’d asked the Christmas Councillor to go up with me. He declined, citing fear of heights, but I went up anyway, later writing that since my staunchly anti-market stance in 2024, “I return with my tail between my legs to tell you that I am now entirely pro-market because of one thing and one thing alone” (it was the wheel).

Pat Karney (right) has a ride on the Christmas Carousel. Photo: Ophira Gottlieb.

But now things are on an entirely different level. While last year I dabbled in the occasional festive spin, this year I’m catching myself doing things that 2024-me would have balked at: eating bratwurst, drinking gluhwein, humming along to George Michael’s Last Christmas as I wander between the archery stall and No. 10 North. Last Friday, in the early clutches of a cold, I spent the whole working day alternating between off-brand Lemsip and mulled wine, creating an effect reminiscent of ‘purple drank’ and resulting in this loosely edited weekend read. Was it the sizzurp, or the “intoxicating Christmas atmosphere across our markets,” as Karney had previously claimed?

No, there’s to be no two ways about it: this year, the Christmas markets are actually good. You might not believe me; you might think the worms in the festive wooden Germanic-inspired ornaments have made their way to my brain — but it’s a fact. And to prove it, I’ve told the Mill team that they can have free reign of the company card for an hour, if they can only put aside their journalistic integrity and wholeheartedly argue my case.

Cranking the raisable Bratwurst grill. Photo: Ethan Penny.

Ok, ok, we appreciate not everyone will be convinced by this argument. If you want to skip the markets, market street, the city centre, Amazon and shopping altogether, you can get your loved ones a Mill subscription for Christmas.

They’re going cheap as well: £15 for three months, £30 for six, or £49.99 for the whole year. Grab ‘em while you can.

Gift The Mill

This story is free to read - you just need to join our mailing list. And why wouldn't you? By becoming a Mill subscriber, you'll get our scoops, features, and insights into Manchester, in your inbox, the second we hit publish. No card details required.

Already have an account? Sign In


Latest