Newhey in the borough of Rochdale is the type of Pennine village that comes into its own this time of year. In late Autumn, its soot-painted, limestone terraced cottages sit huddled against the frosting air. Dew-covered hills lie at both ends of the main street.
The Bird in Hand pub has been shut since the summer of 2018. Local legend has it that the impulsive former owner of the Samuel Smith’s brewery, Humphrey Smith, walked into the pub one day to find the sole member of bar staff using her phone. Frequenters of Sam Smith’s pubs – such as Sinclair’s Oyster Bar in the city centre – will know that phones (and swearing) are strictly banned within the boozers.

As was his wont, the now-deceased Humphrey shut the place down immediately, pouring the regulars’ half-drank pints into the sink as he cleared the room in a flurry. Humphrey’s penchant for shuttering pubs on a whim is well recorded across the country, but this time it ended badly for him. According to one local I met who was there that night, the whole debacle resulted in Humphrey’s luxury car tyres being sliced.
The Bird in Hand is now on the market for £225,000 — or, rather, it was. As this story was being written, the listing was taken down, as were three other Sam Smith’s pubs for sale in Rochdale and Oldham. In fact, around 20 of their establishments which were on the market just a couple of weeks ago have simultaneously disappeared from various property sites. I have chased both the brewery and the selling agents Fleurets for an explanation, but not heard back.

A change of heart? Perhaps. But there was something in the listing of those pubs that caught The Mill’s eye. The Bird in Hand, as well Oldham's Commercial Inn, and the Riflemans Arms and The Grapes in Rochdale, were being sold on the condition that they can’t be brought back to life as pubs once more. Each listing came with the stipulation that they were for “NON-PUB use only”.

Hi, this is Alec, the writer of this pub mystery about the dynasty of the highly eccentric Humphrey Smith, and what his passing – and succession by his son – means for Greater Manchester’s pubs.
You can carry on reading below, but only if you’re one of the more than 5000 paying Mill members. A subscription costs £8.95 a month, or £89 for a year.
What isn’t a mystery is what you get with this subscription — the best investigations, features and culture writing in Greater Manchester.
This article is for paying members only
Join The Mill for full access to this story, plus four great features delivered to your inbox every week — and the knowledge that you're supporting a new model of local news that puts quality and honesty first.
From £8.95/month · cancel anytime
Get full accessAlready have an account? Sign In
